Insights
The Path to Foodservice Profitability: Recap from CSP Daily News Podcast Series with Impact 21
Convenience stores serve a critical need in the retail market by providing quick-and-easy access to snacks, drinks, gas, and basic necessities like toilet paper and bread. But in recent years, one part of the c-store business has rivaled all others as the hot growth area: Foodservice. And more importantly, foodservice profitability.
According to data from the NACS State of the Industry survey, total foodservice sales in convenience stores increased by 14.3% in 2022. Yet despite such impressive growth, industry leaders continue to face daunting operational and managerial challenges.
To unpack these and offer solutions to industry leaders, Liza Salaria, Practice Lead for Category Management and Foodservice at Impact 21, participated in a three-part podcast with CSP Daily News Senior Editor Hannah Hammond. Here are the key takeaways from their conversation.
Takeaway No. 1: Create a foodservice operating P&L
“The ability to improve the profitability of your foodservice program starts with knowing your numbers—and ultimately what is driving these numbers,” Salaria said in Part 1 of the podcast series.
As a first step, Salaria suggests coding the largest expense items with a direct relationship to foodservice sales, which is often led by “labor” and “food supplies”. This creates a clearer picture of program profitability, she said.
Salaria employed this simple yet powerful P&L tool to measure the sales and margin incrementality compared to direct expenses and investments when she expanded a foodservice program for Fresh Food. In introducing menu items like sandwiches and smoothies, Fresh Food had to invest in panini presses and blenders and training for staff—but with scant visibility into how investments in new equipment, new operational processes, and, ultimately, cannibalization to existing business were impacting the bottom line. Only when Salaria created a foodservice P&L was she and her team able to understand what was driving down profitability.
To truly understand the impact your foodservice program is having to the total convenience business, Salaria recommends incorporating a “market basket” impact into P&Ls. This affords companies a view the combination of other c-store products being purchased in conjunction with food within the same transaction finance and accounting teams can then predict revenue and profit losses if these food items were to be discontinued.
In the main, the real risk of not being intentional with your P&L, Salaria says, is making a macro decision to remove a food category or program altogether when it may actually be driving a significant amount of customer trips and driving sales of other categories.
Read More Highlights from Part 1
Takeaway No. 2: Take a holistic view of waste
According to Salaria and Beth Hoffer, vice president of operations and foodservice of Weigel’s convenience stores, companies should look beyond just traditional “food” waste.
At Weigel’s, for example, Hoffer and her team focused on understanding the precise physical “movement” of employees. That meant asking themselves hard questions. What tools are necessary to make a pizza? How often do workers need to shift from one place to another to complete their task? What changes could be made to the physical kitchen layout to increase efficiency?
In Salaria’s experience, the waste of “overprocessing” can be just as costly as an inefficient kitchen design. In one example, kitchen employees of a fast-casual chain were “pre-portioning” roughly five to six ounces of French fries for each order from a five-pound bag. While well-intentioned, this work was wasting precious employee time. The more efficient solution, Salaria said, was to give workers a five-ounce measuring scoop and have them process orders in real time.
“Retailers should always look upstream to their suppliers—to work with them to package and ship the product in a manner that’s optimal for their kitchen and their work design,” Salaria said in Part 2 of the podcast series.
Read More Highlights from Part 2
Takeaway No. 3: Focus your menu
A critical component of foodservice profitability is the menu. To Salaria, a c-store’s menu must be unique and executed with razor-sharp efficiency.
Two companies executing their menus with discipline and efficiency are American fast-casual chains Chick-fil-A and Chipotle Mexican Grill. Chick-fil-A focuses on chicken while Chipotle emphasizes fresh modern Mexican bowls, tacos, and burritos. In both cases, the value proposition to the consumer is variety, quality and speed—made possible through a core set of ingredients cooked with one method and assembled on one production line.
There is good reason for this. Introducing a unique new menu outside the core menu and set of ingredients could require “unique equipment, unique processes and a unique work design,” Salaria noted in Part 3 of the podcast series.
“It doesn’t matter how scrumptious your food items are if you can’t make money doing it,” Salaria said.
Read More Highlights from Part 3
Measure foodservice holistically.
It has never been more important to understand how your foodservice program is performing, not only as a standalone restaurant business but as a catalyst for customer and revenue growth for the entire c-store business. While it can take some time to get all the pillars of profitability right, developing a foodservice operating P&L, taking a holistic view of waste, and focusing your menu will allow you to see the impact of foodservice to your total business.
Related Insights
Why You Need an Automation Journey Map
Investment isn’t enough. To maximize the potential of retail automation technology, companies need a deliberate approach. Most of the business […]
Convenience Store Midwest Showdown CONTINUES!
A new year is well underway and the convenience store competition in the Midwest continues to make weekly news. Last […]
Turn Your Customer-First Mantra Into Strategic Action
Retailers have been saying it for years, “We need to put the customer at the center of everything we do.” […]
CSP Magazine – Ticking Tech Timeline and the Potential of AI
This article, by Impact 21’s Tom Newbould as a guest author, was published in the January 2024 edition of CSP […]
Want to stay in touch? Subscribe to the Newsletter